You paid the toll authority directly and the rental company billed it anyway
Several toll roads let rental drivers pay directly by plate: the Bay Area bridges up to 30 days before or 48 hours after, The Toll Roads in Orange County within 5 days, the I-10 Express Lanes up to 30 days before or 5 days after. If you did that and still got a rental charge, the processor charged a toll that was already paid.
What to collect
- Your payment receipt from the toll authority, with plate and date.
- The rental agreement showing the same plate.
- The rental company’s toll receipt.
Whether you paid in time
Windows are strict. A payment after the window can be treated as a violation, and then the rental processor may already have been billed.
Ask for both parts back
Ask for the duplicate toll and the daily fee for that day. Avis’s FAQ tells you to contact customer service in exactly this case.
Want the letter written for you?
We fill in a dispute letter from your answers: the calculation, the terms you rely on and what you ask for. A letter template you review and send yourself. Not legal advice.
Build my letter, $7.99 or see all options
Full refund within 14 days if you haven't downloaded your letter. We don’t promise any outcome.